Skip to content
Impact Communications

The Greenwashing Trap: How Good Organisations End Up Making Bad Claims, and How to Stop

Most greenwashing isn't a conspiracy. It's a rushed caption, a vague word or a leafy logo on the wrong product. A practical checklist to make sure your sustainability claims survive scrutiny.

Here’s how greenwashing usually happens.

It’s Thursday afternoon. A campaign launches on Monday. The design agency has sent beautiful visuals: soft greens, a leaf motif, a sunrise over a field. The marketing manager writes a headline: “Our new packaging: better for the planet.” The comms officer adds a line about the company’s “commitment to sustainability”. Legal is on leave. Nobody asks what “better” means, compared to what, or whether anyone can prove it.

On Monday, the campaign goes out. On Tuesday, a sustainability researcher on social media asks a simple question: better how? By Wednesday, the post has thousands of shares, and the word “greenwashing” is trending next to the brand’s name.

Nobody set out to deceive anyone. But that doesn’t matter. Trust, once dented, is very hard to repair.

What greenwashing is

Greenwashing is when an organisation makes environmental claims that are misleading, exaggerated or unsupported. That includes words, numbers, images, colours, labels and even what you leave out.

It’s becoming riskier every year. Regulators in several markets are tightening rules on green claims. Consumers are more sceptical. Climate-literate journalists, activists and researchers are quick to investigate. And social media means a single post can travel around the world before your comms team has had breakfast.

The ten-point checklist

Run every environmental claim through these questions before it goes out.

1. Is it specific?

“Eco-friendly”, “green”, “sustainable”, “planet-positive” and “natural” are vague. They invite scrutiny you can’t answer. Say exactly what you mean.

Vague: “Our packaging is sustainable.”
Specific: “Our packaging is made from 60% recycled cardboard and is recyclable in Nairobi’s kerbside collection.”

2. Can you prove it?

Every claim needs evidence you could show a journalist or regulator tomorrow. If the data doesn’t exist, the claim doesn’t go out.

3. Are you hiding a bigger problem?

Highlighting one green feature while staying silent about a much larger negative impact is one of the most common forms of greenwashing. A bank that celebrates its paperless statements while financing new coal plants is an obvious example.

4. Are you clear about “carbon neutral” and “net zero”?

These terms attract more scrutiny than almost any others. If your claim depends heavily on carbon offsets, say so, explain their quality and prioritise real emissions cuts first. Many credible frameworks now treat offsets as a supplement, not a substitute.

5. Is your imagery making claims your words can’t?

Leaves, forests, green colour palettes and pristine nature photos on a high-emission product can mislead as effectively as words. Imagery is a claim.

6. Are you confusing goals with achievements?

“We aim to reach net zero by 2040” and “we are net zero” are very different statements. Be crystal clear about what’s done and what’s planned. Show progress against your goals publicly.

7. Are your certifications real and relevant?

Third-party standards and certifications add credibility, if they’re rigorous and actually relevant to the claim. Self-invented badges and seals do the opposite.

8. Have you shown your working?

Publish your data, methods and progress reports. Transparency is the best protection against accusations of greenwashing.

9. Would you welcome a hard question?

If a journalist asked you to justify the claim on live radio, could you? If you’d be nervous, rethink it.

10. Do communications and operations match?

The fastest route to greenwashing is a comms team promising things the business isn’t doing. Involve sustainability, legal and operations colleagues in reviewing every environmental claim.

The upside of honesty

Here’s something counterintuitive: admitting where you’re falling short often builds more trust than claiming perfection.

“We’ve cut our operational emissions by 30% since 2020. Our supply chain is harder. Here’s our plan, and here’s where we’re struggling.”

That kind of statement is disarming. It shows you understand the problem, you’re doing real work and you respect your audience’s intelligence.

What to do if you’re accused

Don’t go silent. Don’t get defensive. Acknowledge the concern quickly, share your evidence, correct anything that was wrong and explain what you’ll do differently. My guide to crisis communications for climate organisations covers this in more detail.

For NGOs too

Greenwashing isn’t only a corporate problem. NGOs can overstate impact, exaggerate the number of trees “planted” (but not survived) or partner with companies whose practices undermine their mission. The same standards apply.

Need help reviewing your sustainability messaging before it goes out? My team at Reznick Communications supports brands and NGOs with credible impact communications. Get in touch.

Frequently asked questions

What is greenwashing?

Making environmental claims that are misleading, exaggerated or unsupported, whether in words or imagery.

How can organisations avoid greenwashing?

Be specific, back every claim with evidence, disclose trade-offs, separate goals from achievements and be transparent about offsets.

Cover photo: Nick Fewings on Unsplash

Blair Reznick
Blair Reznick

Impact communications strategist and climate storyteller. Managing Director of Reznick Communications and Founder & CEO of WeAreTELL.