Skip to content
Climate Storytelling

The Photo That Raised Money and Broke Trust: A Guide to Ethical Climate Storytelling

The crying child, the unnamed "victim", the family posed in front of a flooded home. Images like these raise money, and quietly damage the people in them. Here's how to tell powerful climate stories with consent, dignity and agency.

You’ve seen the photograph. Maybe you’ve used one.

A child, maybe six years old, stands in front of a collapsed mud-walled home after a flood. The image is tightly cropped on her face. She looks frightened. The caption reads something like: “Climate change is destroying lives. Donate now.”

She isn’t named. Her parents may not know where the photo will appear. In a few years, she’ll be twelve, and someone will search her village online and find it. She’ll discover that the most widely shared image of her childhood is a picture of her worst day, used by people she never met to raise money she never saw.

The photo worked. Donations came in. And something important was broken.

What ethical storytelling means

Ethical storytelling is the practice of telling stories in ways that respect the dignity, agency, safety and rights of the people in them. In climate communication, where we often tell stories of people facing loss, it’s not optional. It’s the foundation.

The six principles

1. Informed consent, every time

People should understand what you’re recording, where it will appear, who will see it and for how long. They should be able to say no without consequence.

That means explaining clearly, in a language they understand. A signature on an English-language form handed to someone who doesn’t read English is not consent. Consent should also be ongoing: people can change their minds.

2. Dignity over pity

Show people as full human beings with knowledge, skills, opinions and humour. A farmer facing drought is also an expert in her land. A young man displaced by floods is also a son, a student, a football fan.

Ask yourself: are we showing who this person is, or only what happened to them?

3. Agency over victimhood

Show what people are doing, not only what’s being done to them. Communities hit by climate disasters organise, rebuild, adapt and advocate. That’s the story.

4. Let people speak for themselves

Quote people directly, in their own words. Let them describe their own experience. Better still, give them the camera, the microphone or the pen.

5. Do no harm

Some details put people at risk: exact locations, faces of children, information about health, immigration status or conflict. Think about stigma, safety and privacy. With children, be especially careful.

6. Give back

Share the finished story with the people in it. Better still, involve them in shaping it before publication. If a story creates value, through donations, awards or attention, think about how the community benefits.

The simple test

Before publishing anything, ask one question:

Would the person in this story be proud to see it?

Not tolerate it. Be proud of it. If the answer is no, or you’re not sure, go back and rethink it.

“But pity raises more money”

This is the argument I hear most often, and it deserves an honest answer.

Pity-based imagery can raise money in the short term. But audiences are increasingly sceptical of it, and some research on charity communications suggests that portraying people with agency can be just as effective, or more so, while building longer-term trust. Pity also reinforces stereotypes that shape how investors, policymakers and the public see entire regions, especially Africa.

And communities that feel exploited stop cooperating. The next time you need their story, the door is closed.

Ethical storytelling isn’t a trade-off between doing good and doing well. Over time, it’s both.

Practical tools for your team

  • Consent forms in local languages, explained verbally, with a copy left with the person.
  • Video consent where literacy is a barrier.
  • Image guidelines for staff, photographers and partners: no close-ups of distressed children, no unnamed “victims”, always captions with context.
  • Community review: share stories with community representatives before publishing.
  • A takedown policy: if someone asks for their image to be removed, remove it.

Why this matters to me

At WeAreTELL, ethical storytelling isn’t a policy we follow. It’s the reason we exist. The stories of Earth’s people, places and ecosystems belong to the people who live them. Our job is to help tell them, with consent, dignity and a focus on solutions.

Ethics sits at the heart of everything I’ll be teaching through ImpactComms. If your organisation wants to build an ethical storytelling policy, let’s work together.

Frequently asked questions

What is ethical storytelling?

Telling stories in ways that respect the dignity, agency, safety and rights of the people featured, with informed and ongoing consent.

How do I know if a story is ethical?

Ask whether the person in the story would be proud to see it. If the answer is no, or you’re unsure, rethink it.

Cover photo: Annie Spratt on Unsplash

Blair Reznick
Blair Reznick

Impact communications strategist and climate storyteller. Managing Director of Reznick Communications and Founder & CEO of WeAreTELL.